Hedge Fund vs Private Equity: Which is Better?

Open DBS Treasures Account

For high-net-worth individuals (HNIs), non-resident Indians (NRIs), and institutional investors, wealth management decisions often involve choosing between hedge funds vs private equity. Both investment vehicles offer high-return opportunities but differ in structure, investment horizon, risk, and liquidity. Understanding the difference between hedge funds and private equity is crucial to making an informed choice. This article explores the private equity fund vs hedge fund debate and helps determine which is better suited for your investment strategy.

What is a Hedge Fund?

A hedge fund is an alternative investment vehicle that focuses on generating high returns through aggressive strategies. These funds are managed by professional investors and are subject to fewer regulations compared to mutual funds. The term "hedge" implies protection against financial losses, though hedge funds often involve significant risk.

Types of Hedge Fund Strategies

Hedge funds adopt diverse strategies to capitalise on market opportunities. Some of the most common ones include:

1. Long/ Short Equity – Buying stocks expected to rise and short-selling those expected to fall.
2. Global Macro – Investing based on economic trends worldwide.
3. Event-Driven – Capitalising on corporate events like mergers and bankruptcies.

What is a Private Equity Fund?

A private equity fund invests directly in private companies or buys out public companies to delist them. It focuses on long-term value creation by restructuring businesses, improving operations, and eventually selling them for a profit.

Stages of a Private Equity Investment

1. Venture Capital – Investing in startups with high growth potential.
2. Growth Equity – Providing capital to mature businesses for expansion.
3. Buyouts – Acquiring controlling stakes in established companies.

How to invest in Private Equity and Hedge Funds?

Before we settle hedge funds vs private equity debate for your wealth management decisions, it is important to have a clear understanding for financial goals, risk appetite, and liquidity needs. Since these investments typically demand substantial capital, they are best suited for institutional investors, HNIs and NRIs.

Many investors first allocate their funds to a premium savings account with a bank like DBS Treasures to ensure easy accessibility before transitioning into alternative investments.

• Hedge Funds – Typically accessed through accredited fund managers who employ diverse strategies to generate returns.
• Private Equity Funds – Require long-term capital commitment, with profits realised only upon company exit or IPO.

Private Equity vs. Hedge Fund: Key Differences

While both options fall under alternative investments, they differ significantly in key aspects. The table below highlights the main distinctions:

Private Equity Hedge Fund: Are There Hybrid Models?

Some investment firms blend hedge fund and private equity strategies, creating a private equity hedge fund model. These funds employ a mix of long-term private investments with short-term trading strategies, offering diversification benefits.

Which is Better for Investors: Hedge Fund vs Private Equity

Choosing between hedge funds vs. private equity depends on an investor’s financial goals and risk appetite.

• For short-term traders - Hedge funds provide flexibility and liquidity.
• For long-term wealth creation – Private equity offers higher potential returns.
• For NRIs and HNIs – A structured wealth management approach is essential in determining the best fit.
• Many investors use a premium savings account with banks such as DBS Treasures to manage liquidity before committing to these investments. 

Conclusion

Before choosing between private equity fund vs hedge fund, it’s important to understand their merits and risks. While hedge funds are ideal for those seeking liquidity and market-driven returns, private equity is better suited for patient investors willing to wait for high-value exits. Consulting a financial expert can help determine the right investment strategy for your portfolio.

*This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investments in hedge funds and private equity carry risks, and it is advisable to consult a professional financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

• Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG) Tax on Equity Mutual Funds

Selling equity mutual fund units within one year incurs 20% STCG tax under the Income Tax Bill 2025. This higher rate increases tax liability for short-term investors.

• Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) Tax on Equity Mutual Funds

For units held beyond one year, LTCG tax is now 12.5%, affecting long-term investors. Understanding equity taxation in mutual funds helps in planning tax-efficient investments.

• Dividend Taxation on Equity Mutual Funds

Under the latest equity mutual fund taxation rules, dividends from equity mutual funds are taxed as per the investor’s income slab. 

Key Tax Rules:

• Taxable as per Slab Rate: Dividend income is added to total income and taxed accordingly.
• TDS on Dividends: If dividend income exceeds INR 5,000 in a financial year, 10% TDS is deducted.

Investors in higher tax brackets face increased liability, making it essential to understand equity taxation in mutual funds for better financial planning.

Tax-Saving Strategies for Equity Mutual Fund Investors

Optimising equity mutual fund taxation can help investors lower tax liability and improve returns. Here are some key strategies:

1. Tax-Loss Harvesting

Offset tax on equity mutual funds by selling investments at a loss to reduce taxable capital gains. The sold investments can be repurchased later to maintain market exposure.

2. Utilise the ₹1 Lakh LTCG Exemption

LTCG up to ₹1 lakh per financial year is tax-free. Investors can redeem investments strategically within this limit to avoid taxation.

3. Choose Growth Over Dividend Option

Dividends are taxed at the investor’s slab rate, making them less tax-efficient. The growth option allows deferring tax until redemption, reducing overall liability.

 

4. Use Systematic Withdrawals

A Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) spreads redemptions over time, keeping capital gains within lower tax brackets and optimising tax efficiency.

By leveraging these strategies and understanding equity taxation in mutual funds, investors can enhance post-tax returns.

How to File Taxes on Equity Mutual Fund Gains

1. Report Gains & Dividend Income:

• File returns via the Income Tax e-Filing Portal.
• Declare capital gains under "Capital Gains" and dividends under "Income from Other Sources."

2. Optimise Your MF Portfolio for Tax Efficiency:

• Structured redemptions and a diversified MF portfolio help manage tax liability.
• Premium banking services like DBS Treasures Premium Account provide tax-efficient wealth management and personalised financial guidance.

3. Maintain Proper Records:

• Keep transaction details and investment statements ready for smooth tax filing.

By managing tax on equity mutual funds efficiently, investors can reduce liabilities while maximising post-tax returns.

Conclusion

Before choosing between private equity fund vs hedge fund, it’s important to understand their merits and risks. While hedge funds are ideal for those seeking liquidity and market-driven returns, private equity is better suited for patient investors willing to wait for high-value exits. Consulting a financial expert can help determine the right investment strategy for your portfolio.

For NRIs and HNIs looking to diversify globally, opening an NRI account with DBS can provide seamless access to international investments, better fund management, and smooth remittance options—making your transition into hedge funds or private equity more efficient and compliant.

*This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investments in hedge funds and private equity carry risks, and it is advisable to consult a professional financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Open DBS Treasures Account